The US efforts to curb illegal immigration have been stupidly focused. Don’t get me wrong, I believe we should have strong borders and enforcement to prevent people coming in illegally. I applaud realistic efforts to strengthen border protections. We shouldn’t let “just anybody” come into the country without at least having some assurance that their intentions are in line with ours.
I find it ridiculous, though, that it’s easier for somebody to come across the border illegally and live on the fringes of society than it is for somebody to come to the country legally. And then those who are here legally are subject to the short-sighted whims of political parties. During the first Trump administration our team of eight people at Amazon lost two employees for more than six months because immigration laws changed and they were suddenly no longer authorized to work. They were able to stay in the country, but because of some particular rule change or Congress’s lack of action on something, their authorization to work expired and there was no way to renew it.
Millions of people who had jumped through all of the immigration hoops, had obeyed all the regulations, filled out all the forms, owned houses, had kids, contributed to the economy and paid taxes were treated as outsiders, at best, if not suspected criminals. Some were found to have inadvertently missed a filing date and were summarily exported. 10 years or more in the country as model guests and then Boom! Kicked out. Not only did the companies who sponsored their visas lose valuable employees, the nation turned millions of friends into enemies. The economic losses pale in comparison to the loss of trust and goodwill.
Stupid.
The ongoing debate about the “Dreamers,” children of parents who came to the country illegally decades ago, is even dumber. These children, now adults, have known no other home but the United States. They have families themselves, steady jobs, own homes and businesses, pay taxes, and extoll the virtues of living in the United States. But because their parents brought them here illegally decades ago they are under constant threat of having their lives destroyed by political whim.
Forget the moral arguments, whether it’s “right” that they should be allowed to stay or whether it’s “right” that we should destroy somebody’s life because their parents didn’t do the right thing. Think instead of the economic cost and the loss of goodwill. Nothing good comes from forcing these Americans, which they are in all but name, to leave the country and start a new life somewhere that they’ve never been. Well, nothing good except for some politician to placate his over-zealous supporters by showing that he’s “tough on immigration” and “doing something about the problem” by turning productive, tax-paying friends into implacable enemies.
“Stupid” doesn’t even begin to describe it.